I decided to make some marshmallows from scratch. It took several batches and recipes before they came out just the way I had imagined. Once you find the perfect recipe, the process to make them before they have to set, only takes 30 to 40 minutes. There are many recipes out there and the outcome can be different depending on how many gelatin packets it calls for, the temperature you boil your sugar syrup to or whether you use corn syrup. I also make the caramel as the marshmallows are mixing in the stand mixer. The marshmallows take at least 8 to 12 hours to set.
I made these with organic cacao powder and it gives them a nice rich chocolate taste. This recipe was slightly different then the caramel ones as you have to incorporate the cacao paste into the mix before you pour your sugar syrup into the mixer.

These were the first Caramel one's that I made. I did not use corn syrup and they came out much lighter than what I was going for. I used brown rice syrup in the caramel and it had a nice flavor.

I was very happy how my last caramel batch came out. I poured my marshmallow batter in a round pan, but I would use a square one next time. Besides coating the pan with vegetable oil and powdered sugar, I added a piece of parchment paper on the bottom so that I can turn it over on a cutting surface. I also drizzled the caramel over the top of the marshmallow batter after I poured it in the pan. I then swirled it with a skewer. I let my batch sit overnight before I cut into it.

I found a nice French recipe for salted butter caramel from David Leblebovitz that complimented the marshmallows insanely well. I mean this was so amazing and delicious that people told me to sell them. I did not boil my syrup to the complete 310ºF as I did not want my caramel to be so solid. I believe I boiled it around 270ºF. I also used organic brown rice syrup which gives it a nice flavor. I'd love to also try this recipe with crème fraîche.


I'd love to try and make them all vegan with some type of gelatin alternative and just brown rice syrup instead of corn, but i'm not sure if it's possible. One of my batches with just brown rice syrup did not come out correctly, so I'd have to make several more attempts to get it right.